GUEST OPINION

Alhambra City Hall (Photo – Frank Qiu)
A hot topic in Alhambra City Council is a people-powered initiative on the November 2020 ballot, which would amend the Alhambra City Charter to make elections in Alhambra fairer.
By Melissa Michelson
The ballot initiative is called “The Alhambra Election and Campaign Finance Reform Act.” However, in April, three Councilmembers voted to place a competing measure on the Nov. 2020 ballot meant to confuse voters and defeat the citizen-led measure.
Shortly after proposing a countermeasure that would have sought solidification of at-large elections, City Hall received demand letters from multiple attorney’s stating that the City’s current at-large electoral system violates the California Voting Rights Act. If the three Councilmembers were to press forward with their countermeasure, it would be undemocratic and likely unlawful. In light of all of these developments, City Hall and the proponents of the citizen-led ballot measure appear to have come to agreeable terms on a consensus measure that is a variant of the original grassroots measure. Now, a special council meeting has been called for Tuesday, June 2 at 9:30 am for a first reading of the “consensus measure” to be placed on the November 2020 ballot, along with another ballot measure to release the school district from the City’s charter so that AUSD can also transition to by-district elections.
A little background
Last month, Councilmembers Maza, Maloney and Mejia intended to put forth their own ballot initiative as a counter-measure, purporting to limit campaign donations to City councilmembers, but the grassroots initiative supported by the 8,500+ Alhambrans who signed the petition two years ago to include it on the November 2020 ballot would limit donations to a maximum of $250, and it also would move the City from at-large to by-district voting.
At the April 27, 2020, City Council meeting, Mayor Ross Maza and Councilmembers Jeff Maloney and David Mejia voted to put their own competing ballot initiative before voters on the November ballot. At the time, the language for the competing initiative had not yet been created but direction was given to the city attorney to include a campaign donation limit and maintain at-large voting.
The problem with that proposal is that excluding by-district voting is not conducive to representative democracy and handily favors the corporate and establishment elite in the City. There are five districts in Alhambra with one Councilperson per district. The people actually living in those districts should be able to select their representative to the City Council rather than having their votes diluted by the power of a monied constituency group affecting votes across districts.
The donation cap and by-district voting work together. If the City has at-large voting that also includes a donation cap, which is what the three Councilmembers wanted, it would be virtually impossible for grassroots or lower-income candidates to run a City-wide campaign. City-wide campaigns are more expensive than district-only campaigns. City-wide campaigns require City connections or big donors, which establishment candidates have.
At-Large Voting is Cost-Prohibitive
In 2018, many of Alhambra’s recurring corporate donors and heavy hitters joined forces and formed the “Alhambrans United” Political Action Committee (PAC) to support real estate friendly candidates for City Council: Laura Tellez-Gagliano and realtor Suzi Dunkel-Soto, who has been on the City’s Planning Commission for several years. The PAC amassed at least $24,500, and spent at least $24,306 to help Tellez-Gagliano and Dunkel-Soto win, primarily through negative mailers. Contributors to the PAC included Alhambra airsoft gun super-store Evike.com, developers James Chou and Kenneth Sim, city contractor Brad Perrin and more who invested thousands of dollars each in the PAC to elect these two candidates. (Click to see who is part of the Alhambrans United PAC).
The Alhambrans United PAC paid for expensive mailers, postage and even street sign-spinners promoting Dunkel-Soto and Tellez-Gagliano. Sending mailers to residents across Alhambra’s eight miles cost over $20,000 at the time. If Alhambra had by-district voting, such materials would have cost 1/5 that amount making campaigning more possible for candidates who don’t benefit from friends in high places or PACs.
Likewise, 2016 campaign finance reports show that then-candidates David Mejia and Jeff Maloney spent upwards of $40,000 each on their City-wide campaigns.
At the April 27 Council meeting, District 1 current City Councilwoman, Katherine Lee, confirmed that her own City-wide campaign easily cost $4000-5000 for a single mailer to go out to all registered Alhambra voters.
Consensus Ballot Measure
Grassroots Alhambra has worked on a “consensus ballot measure” that would include campaign finance reform and by-district city council elections, and are asking the public to call in and speak or submit a letter of support to be read into the public record. In an email to its members, Grassroots Alhambra explained that the consensus measure is a “variant of our original measure and Grassroots Alhambra’s Board of Directors support it. It is the product of negotiations with the Alhambra City Council at the City’s request. The goal was to have a unity measure that had the broadest support of everyone in the City.”
Some of the changes from the original grassroots-signed petition include extending the time period that city council members can start campaigning for their re-election to 18 months, compared to 9 months in the original measure. Also, winning candidates would be able to keep $6,000 in their campaign accounts after election compared to $5,000 as written into the original ballot measure. In addition, a ban on certain entities donating directly to a city council candidate’s campaign was added to the measure.
You can view more information about the meeting and the consensus measure at the City Council Special Meeting Agenda (06/03/2020).
Melissa Michelson is an active resident of Alhambra.
The Guest Opinion section reflects the opinions of the responsible contributor(s)/writer(s) only, and do not reflect the viewpoint of ColoradoBoulevard.net. ColoradoBoulevard.net does not endorse or guarantee the accuracy of any posting. ColoradoBoulevard.net accepts no obligation to review every posting, but reserves the right (with no obligation) to delete comments and postings that may be considered offensive, illegal or inappropriate.









Leave a Reply