• Editorials

      A Better Path for Pasadena Unified: Vision First, Decisions Next

      GUEST OPINION

      open doors into a hallway

      An open door to a shared vision for Pasadena Unified (Photo – Colorado Boulevard Newspaper)

      Pasadena Unified School District is at a crossroads. One path begins with an honest vision for public education, developed with families, students, educators, and the broader community. The other begins with a school closure plan whose destination appears to have been chosen before the public has been meaningfully heard.

      By Warren Bleeker

      Superintendent Dr. Elizabeth Blanco has identified the better path for transforming the District. Before deciding whether to close schools, PUSD must define what it wants its schools to become: which programs and models are working, what students need, how campuses can serve their communities, and what investments will strengthen educational opportunity across the district. Facts should inform that vision, and the community should help create it.

      Dr. Blanco has said school closure is “not the vision.” She acknowledges the missteps of the earlier Total School Solutions process, and promises to start earlier, make the facts accessible, listen across the community, and show how public input shapes the result. That is the foundation of a credible transformation process. As Dr. Blanco put it, “We can do better.”

      Start with a shared vision—not a closure plan

      There is a disconnect between the four Board members pushing a school closure plan and the Superintendent, Student Assembly, and three other Board members, who favor a visioning process. That divide is reflected in the agenda for the October 8 Board meeting: a thoughtful visioning presentation alongside continued discussion of Kimberly K. Kenne’s school closure Resolution 2894, including an action item on “how to proceed with finalizing the definition of the District Transformation Process referenced in Resolution 2894.”

      Let the
      newly elected
      Board lead
      the district
      into the future”

      Part of that “definition” is to “Consolidate schools . . . to achieve the goals contained in this definition of the District Transformation Process.” Less than a month before the election, the four Board members—Kimberly K. Kenne, Tina Fredericks, Scott Harden, and Yarma Velazquez—appear to be fast-tracking a definition of transformation that already makes school closure its end goal. On August 13, 2026, Tina Fredericks identified the schools she wants to close under Resolution 2894, including the “receiving” schools, despite the district’s open enrollment policy.

      The cleanest course is to abandon this divisive resolution and begin again under Dr. Blanco’s framework. This would not rule out difficult decisions; it would put them in the proper order: vision first, reliable information second, genuine student, family, educator, and community deliberation third, and only then consideration of structural changes that may—or may not—be necessary. Let the newly elected Board lead the district into the future.

      If the Board keeps Resolution 2894, it must comply with its conditions

      If a Board majority insists on continuing under Resolution 2894, it must at least follow the procedure the resolution requires. Before directing the scope of the transformation process, establishing a committee structure, or selecting committee members and a chair, the Board must receive the Superintendent’s presentation of projected district enrollment for the next five to ten years, including school-site projections where available; updated school-site capacity reports; background data from the 2026 consolidation process; and current staffing levels at each school. Meaningfully compiling this information takes time.

      That sequence matters. The information is meant to guide the Board’s choices, not arrive as an afterthought when the process’s structure, direction, and end result have long been decided. Moving ahead in this fashion repeats the mistakes of the past. It disregards the Board’s own adopted procedure and reinforces the concern that the outcome is being engineered in advance.

      Do not make another unforced error

      Let the community
      help shape
      what comes
      next”

      In July, after serious transparency and Brown Act violations were alleged, Tina Fredericks, Kimberly K. Kenne, Scott Harden, and Yarma Velazquez agreed to stop engaging in serial communications prohibited by the Brown Act. The Board then canceled its August 31 special meeting midway through because it had violated the Brown Act. The September 3 make-up meeting also violated the Brown Act, and the district acknowledged that “a mistake was made regarding President Fredericks’ remote attendance at the September 3 Special Board meeting for the Committee of the Whole.”

      Pressing ahead without following Resolution 2894’s procedure would be another unforced error. It could trigger unnecessary litigation, consume public resources, delay planning, and further erode trust.

      The Board has a clear choice: take Dr. Blanco’s path and conduct actual visioning before considering closure or consolidation. Abandon Resolution 2894 and replace it with a process designed to unite rather than divide the community.

      Support Independent Local Journalism This Holiday Season

      We hope you enjoyed this article. We live in and care deeply about this community, and we’re grateful to be part of it.

      For more than a decade, Colorado Boulevard Newspaper has investigated local issues, asked difficult questions, and worked to hold power accountable; free from shareholders, corporate agendas, and outside influence..

      Your support helps make the time, research, and reporting behind these stories possible.

      A $5 gift or subscription can help keep independent local journalism strong, this holiday season and all year long.

      Please explore the many ways to support us by clicking the button below.

      Support

      Author

      Comments

      1. Erin says:

        This is absolutely spot on. When certain board members keep pushing resolutions for closures while simultaneously working on “visioning”, it’s clear what their predetermined vision is.

      Leave a Reply

      Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *